{"courtSectionTextID":861,"courtID":2,"title":"Court Procedures","sectionText":"

55TH District Court Procedures

I.     COURTROOM DECORUM 

All litigants and counsel are expected to show respect for each other and the Court. As such, litigants and counsel should:

  1. Stand when the jury and the judge enters and exits the courtroom. 
  2. Stand when talking to the judge. 
  3. Request permission to approach the bench or the witness.  
  4. Do not interrupt opposing counsel or witnesses.  You will have a full opportunity to address the court. 
  5. Address the judge, opposing counsel or witnesses professionally and respectfully.
  6. You may examine witnesses at the counsel table or from a podium.  
  7. Address the witness as \"Mr.\" or \"Ms.\"

Please read the attached Administrative Order and The Texas Lawyer's Creed a Mandate For Professionalism  /JustexDocuments/3/Admin Order & Lawyer's Creed.PDF and conduct yourself accordingly. 


II.     MOTIONS

All motions and responses must include a proposed order. 

Agreed motions are submitted to the Court for consideration without the need for a hearing. If an agreed motion is denied without a hearing, you can request a subsequent oral hearing on the motion.

In an effort to reduce paper usage, please do not submit courtesy copies of any motion or response. Also, the Court does not need copies of exhibits.

Certificate of Conference

You must confer with opposing counsel prior to filing all motions and include a detailed certificate of conference, with the following exceptions: motions for default judgments, motions for summary judgment, motions to dismiss, plea to jurisdiction, motions to transfer venue, motions for voluntary dismissal/ nonsuits, post-verdict motions, special appearances, and motions involving service of process. Failure to comply may result in the Court passing the hearing.

The Court requires compliance with Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 191.2, which states as follows:

“Parties and their attorneys are expected to cooperate in discovery and to make any agreements reasonably necessary for the efficient disposition of the case. All discovery motions or requests for hearings relating to discovery must contain a certificate by the party filing the motion or request that a reasonable effort has been made to resolve the dispute without the necessity or Court intervention and the effort failed.\"

The Court does not consider the following statements, or the like, to comply with the Rule:

“Sent a letter…did not get a response”

“Left a message…don’t know if the other side agrees or disagrees.”

“The other side won’t return my phone calls.”

“I have attempted to resolve this matter by agreement but was unable to do so.”

The certificate of conference should include a detailed statement of the movant’s efforts to resolve the issues in the motion with opposing counsel/party prior to filing the motion.  If a party was unable to reach the other side prior to filing the motion, the certificate should state the efforts to communicate with that party, and should always be supplemented as soon as possible after the parties have actually conferred and before the hearing on the motion.  Failure to actually confer with the other side or adequately explain why after multiple attempts you were unable to confer before the hearing or submission date may result in your motion being removed from the docket.

Substituted Service

Motions for substituted service are submitted to the Court for consideration without the need for a hearing. The motions must be in strict compliance with Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 106.  The motion should include an affidavit (a) detailing all efforts taken to verify that the defendant actually lives or works at the subject address, (b) multiple attempts of service at different times of day with the specific dates and times, (c) the identity of person(s) present at the subject address and what was said, (d) the identity of the owners of any cars in the driveway or other indications that defendant resides at the subject address; (e) in the proper circumstances, whether the technology actually belongs to the defendant and whether the defendant regularly uses or recently used the technology. Motions should include the attached form order for substituted service here.

Service By Publication

Motions for service by publication must be in strict compliance with Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 109, 116 and 117. The motion should include an affidavit detailing (a) all efforts taken to verify that the residence of the defendant is unknown to the affiant and/or the defendant is a transient person; (b) attempts to locate the whereabouts of the defendant or that the defendant is absent from or is a non-resident of the State; and (c) for a nonresident defendant, that the party applying for citation has attempted to obtain personal service of the nonresident defendant as provided for in Rule 108 but has been unable to do so. Motions should include the attached form order for service by publication here.

Discovery Motions

The Court believes the parties can resolve most discovery disputes without court intervention.  Attorneys must communicate with opposing counsel before filing any motion related to discovery. The motion should include the certificate of conference as discussed above. If parties have not conferred, the hearing on the docket will be passed by the court. Parties with discovery motions pending on the oral hearing docket should arrive at least 15 minutes before their scheduled hearing to confer again with the other side prior to your case being called to the bench.

Discovery motions should specify each specific discovery response at issue and include a copy of the response(s) at issue as sub-documents when e-filing, or state verbatim the request and answer in the body of your motion. 

Proposed orders should list each discovery issue separately so that the court may sign a specific order granting or denying the requested relief.

Default Judgments

All motions for default are heard in an oral hearing only. Default motions are heard at 9:30 a.m. (with live testimony) and 9:45 a.m. (all others) on Monday.

A certificate of service providing proof of service of the notice of hearing on the default on non-movant(s) must be attached to all Default motions. 

A separate certificate of last known address and a proper non-military service affidavit must be attached to the motion. A non-military verification may be obtained by visiting the Defense Manpower Data Center’s (DMDC) Military Verification service at https://scra.dmdc.osd.mil. 

Daubert/ Robinson 

A hearing should be requested pursuant to the Docket Control Order deadlines. All motions to exclude experts should be filed AND set for hearing well in advance of trial (at least 30 days). Do not wait until the eve of or morning of trial to file your motion.

Special Exceptions

Attach a copy of the pleading you are excepting to as an exhibit (unless the exception is only to the amount of damages sought) or state verbatim which paragraphs you except to. Proposed orders should list each exception separately.

 Severances

The party requesting the severance must specifically list all pleadings to be included in the severance order to be transferred to the new file.

III.      HEARINGS

All responses should be filed at least 24 hours before the hearing unless otherwise required at a different time under the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure. The failure to file a written response prior to the hearing or submission date may be considered a representation of no opposition. As a result, the Court may rule on the motion accordingly.

Oral Hearing Docket

Oral hearings are heard on Monday at 9:30am, 9:45am, 10:00am, 11:00am, 1:30pm; Thursday at 8:30am; and Friday at 8:30am

Default motions are heard only at 9:30 a.m. (with live testimony) and 9:45 a.m.(all others) on Mondays.

Discovery motions are heard only at 8:30 a.m. on Thursdays.

Temporary Injunctions are heard only on Fridays at 8:30 a.m.

Docket Calls are set at 9:00 a.m. on Fridays.

Unless it is impractical to do so, all motions involving self-represented individuals should be set for oral hearing with proper notice to all parties. Please contact the Clerk for an assignment of date and time. 

Once you call the Clerk and obtain a hearing date, please file a notice of oral hearing and serve it on all parties. The Court requires at least five (5) days written notice to all parties, unless otherwise shortened by the Court, agreed to by all parties, or the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure require different deadlines. The failure to file a notice of hearing will result in the Court passing the hearing.

In cases assigned for trial at Docket Call, no discovery or other non-trial related motions will be heard by the Court before trial. 

 Submission Hearing Docket

All motions set for submission are heard on Mondays at 8:00 a.m. Motions set for submission must be noticed for submission at least ten (10) days from filing, except on leave of the Court. Submission hearings set without timely notice will result in the Court passing the hearing.

If a movant places a matter on the submission docket, the non-movant may object to consideration of the motion by submission and request to have the matter heard by oral hearing.

Motions for reconsideration are generally placed on the submission docket first.   

Emergency/ Expedited/ Special Hearings 

If both sides agree to an emergency/expedited hearing, call the Clerk and set up a phone conference with the judge or an oral hearing. If only one side feels it is an emergency, e-file a motion for emergency/expedited hearing. Please send a courtesy copy directly to the Clerk who will then give it to the judge to review and set an expedited hearing or provide further guidance to the parties, as appropriate.

In the event that you are unable to secure a hearing date as soon as necessary on the Court's regular oral hearing docket, or if you require a special setting, please file a letter with the Court, and serve it on all parties, requesting a special setting with alternative dates that are convenient for all parties and the date by which you are requesting the matter be heard by the Court. Please send a courtesy copy of the letter to the Clerk who will then give it to the judge for review. 

Motions requiring more than 30 minutes  should request a special setting. 

Appearance Remotely By Video or Phone

Parties and litigants may attend almost all oral hearings remotely by Video or Phone EXCEPT you must appear in-person at the court for the following motions/ settings:

  1. Discovery motions
  2. Temporary Injunctions/ Temporary restraining orders
  3. Contempt/Show Cause Hearings
  4. Pretrial Conferences

Please call the Clerk to obtain permission and instructions to appear by Zoom video or phone for any of the hearings specified above.

Continuances

Generally, the Court will allow one timely asserted continuance. First or second request for continuances should be filed early, but in any event at least 24 hours before the docket call for the case and will be considered at or before the docket call. A hearing prior to the docket call will be required on any request for additional continuances after the first or second request thereafter. The Court requires a reasonable explanation for the request that takes into consideration the current age and status of the case and whether opposing party is prejudiced by further delay.    

Withdraw as Counsel

Before consideration of a motion to withdraw that will leave a client as self-represented, the following must be filed:

  1. Notice of hearing or submission.
  2. A statement of the particular circumstances and disciplinary rules requiring withdrawal. A general statement of “irreconcilable conflicts” is not enough. Matters which are confidential may be filed under seal.
  3. A certificate by the attorney of record of the client’s name, address, and telephone number, whether such information is current, or if not current, when it was last known to be current. If you also have an email address, please include that information as well. A copy of a letter from the attorney of record to the client giving notice: (a) that the attorney is withdrawing; (b) that the client is deemed to have knowledge of and is required to abide by the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure if the client proceeds pro se; (c) that all notices from the Court to the client’s current address will be deemed to have been received unless the client notifies the Court of any change of address; (d) that no continuances or extension will be granted to the pro se client in order to obtain other counsel; and (e) notice of submission or  hearing at which the motion to withdraw will be considered. 
  4. In addition to the items described in #4 above, if the client is a corporation, the attorney must notify the client that a corporation cannot proceed pro se and if the corporation has not obtained new counsel within 30 days, a default judgment may be entered against the corporation if it is a defendant or its claims will be dismissed if it is a plaintiff.
  5. A signed acceptance of the terms of the letter described in item 4, if the client has agreed to the withdrawal.  If the client has not agreed to the withdrawal, proof of service of the letter described in items 4 and 5 must be filed.

 Sanctions

Sanctions should not be requested unless the opponent has violated a previous order and engaged in particularly egregious behavior.

Temporary Injunctions

Temporary injunctions are set on Friday at 8:30 a.m. Please call the Clerk before the scheduled hearing. It is imperative that we know whether or not you are ready to proceed with the hearing and how long the hearing will take. We may need to reschedule your hearing and extend the TRO until a convenient time for the Court. Do not bring your witnesses to Court until you have spoken to the Clerk.


III. TRIAL

All cases are automatically set for trial after the answer of a defendant. If not reached at the first assigned trial setting, most cases are reset within 45 to 60 days. Docket Call is held 25 days before trial on Friday at 9:00 a.m. All parties must appear at Docket Call. NO CONTINUANCES WILL BE GRANTED after Docket Call and once a case is assigned for trial except in extraordinary circumstances that could not have been anticipated by the parties. 

Pretrial

Pretrial conferences are held the morning of trial unless the parties believe more than 45 minutes is needed. If so, please let the Court know at Docket Call or contact the trial coordinator to schedule additional time.

The parties should exchange motions in limine, exhibit lists, witness lists, deposition excerpts and any objections thereto at least five (5) days prior to the assigned trial. Discuss the matters among yourselves and attempt agreements. Be prepared to discuss which of your opponents’ exhibits, witnesses, and limine issues you agree or do not agree upon. Advanced rulings on deposition excerpts are available by request, depending on the case. If you seek an advance ruling, please provide excerpts of deposition testimony with objections prior to pretrial conference.  

Motions in Limine should be specific to the case. Do not duplicate items in your motions in limine. Your motion should be limited to only those items specific to the facts and circumstances in your case. Please refer to the court’s Standing Order in Limine here. The Order automatically applies to all trials held in the 55th District Court.

Voir Dire

Time for voir dire depends on the complexity of the case and will be discussed with the parties during pretrial. During voir dire, general contentions may be stated but the case should not be argued. After the general voir dire, individual jurors may be questioned at the bench for cause, if necessary.

All challenges for cause are ruled on between voir dire and peremptory strikes. Liberal with cause determinations and hardships are provided if I have enough on the panel to seat a jury. The Clerk shall prepare strike list for the lawyers to mark and sign their peremptory challenges.

Questionnaires

Questionnaires are discouraged as they extend the length of voir dire.  If the parties desire questionnaires, a hearing should be set to discuss them in certain cases at an earlier date before the first day of voir dire.

Proposed Jury Charge

Drafts of proposed jury charges should be exchanged PRIOR to pretrial conference. Parties should email or bring a thumb drive with their proposed charge in Word format to the court coordinator, Justin Fitzgerald.

Exhibits

Use numbers for the exhibits, not letters.  Have a list prepared for the Court and another for the court reporter.  Also, parties should provide a hard copy of the exhibits for the court reporter to place in the record.

Law Briefs and Cases

Please brief and/or bring cases on unusual legal and evidentiary issues before the pretrial conference.

 

 

","positionOrder":4,"showAsPage":true,"displayAsPrimary":false,"isViewable":true}